Al Jazeera, NASA, Sheikh(s) ibn Othaymeen, Abdallah al Mani

The following was a question and answer session executed by Br Yasir Butt. Copy of it has been hereby enclosed as forwarded to us. (Portion of it may be slightly modified for flow by

Q:Did you start Shabaan right? Some people started shaban on the 23rd of July (Thursday) while some on the 24th of July 2008 (Friday)?

A: Since the Rasool SAW says: “safeguard the sighting of shabaan so can start Ramadhan right” hadith is authentic in mustadrak hakim volume 1 page 586 published by dar kutub ilmiyya in 1990 edition.

حدّثنا أبو بكر بن إسحاق الفقيه ، أنبأ إسماعيل بن قتيبة ، ثنا يحيى بن يحيى ، أنبأ أبو معاوية ، عن محمد بن عمرو ، عن أبي سلمة ، عن أبي هريرة قال: قال رسول الله: «احْصوا هِلالَ شَعْبانَ لِرَمضانَ». صحيح على شرط مسلم ولم يخرجاه.

المستدرك على الصحيحين

جزء 1

صفحة 586

The 24th of July 2009 is the 1st of Shabaan no doubt, Insha Allah. Consider what the scholars say so we do not fall prey to our emotions.

It is IMPOSSIBLE TO DESIGNATE THURSDAY the 23rd of July 2009 as the first day of Shaban according to Sheikh ibn Othaymeen (Allah have mercy on him) because the day before it the 22nd of July 2009 was a total solar eclipse (when the moon is between the earth and the Sun)

In Arabic this news was covered by Al Jazeera News Service

In English it was covered by NASA:

BBC in its coverage:

Sheikh ibn Othaymeen (Allah have mercy on him)

“إذا وقع كسوف الشمس بعد غروبها في أي مكان في الأرض فإنه يتعذر أن يكون

اليوم التالي أول شهر جديد …..أو أن الجنين يستهل قبل أن يخرج من بطن أمه…….إلخ”

“If a Solar eclipse takes place after sunset in any part of the earth then it is unacceptable that the next day is the 1st day of a new month…….anyone who claims that is like the one who claims that a baby cries before it exits the womb…”

Full fatwa link with translation:


Also Sheikh Abdallah al Mani (Senior Scholar)

شيخ عبدالله المنيع (هيئة كبار العلماء)

As stated in a editorial published in the Arabic news paper called “Al-Muslimoom” volume 622 published on 3 January 1997.

Read the last paragraph

Arabic link of the article:

Translated by Yasir Butt withan added note: “I would like to request the higher judicial council to revise its methodology in announcing new months and to distance our country from perpetual criticism with evidence when we announced new months while there was a solar eclipse that night.”

One response to “Al Jazeera, NASA, Sheikh(s) ibn Othaymeen, Abdallah al Mani